Skip to content
Je Suis HumanCart
Back to articles

How to Compare eCommerce SEO Agencies Side by Side

Most store owners compare SEO agencies the same way they’d compare any supplier: they look at price, read a few case studies and go with the one that feels right. That approach often leads to a decision based on the best pitch, not the best fit.

A structured comparison works better. Whether you start from a referral, a Google search or a ranked list of the best ecommerce seo agency options such as this overview, scoring each agency on the same criteria makes the differences much clearer.

Why a structured comparison matters

Agencies are paid from a shared pot. Gartner’s 2026 CMO Spend Survey, as reported by MediaPost, found that agencies account for 19.2% of the average marketing budget. With budgets flat at around 7.8% of company revenue, every agency euro has to earn its place.

SEO also takes months to show its full effect, so a poor choice is expensive. By the time it becomes clear that an agency isn’t the right fit, half a year may have passed.

A simple scorecard

The table below gives a starting point. Score each agency from 1 to 5 on every row after your first calls and proposals.

Criterion What to look for Questions to ask
eCommerce focus Most clients are online stores What share of your clients sell online?
Platform knowledge Experience with your platform What are the SEO limits of our platform?
Team Senior people on the account Who will we work with every week?
Implementation Can ship changes, not only advise Who makes the changes on our site?
Content Writes category and product content well Can we see examples of category pages you wrote?
Link building Transparent about sources Can we approve sites before links are placed?
Reporting Connects SEO to orders and revenue What does your monthly report show?
International Handles several languages and markets How do you research new countries?
Fit with paid media Understands how SEO and ads work together How do you work with our paid team?

Add up the scores, but also note where an agency scores very low. One weak area, such as no ability to implement changes, can outweigh strong scores elsewhere.

What to ask for in a proposal

A good proposal tells you as much about an agency as the first call. When you compare proposals, check whether each one includes:

  • A clear view of your store’s current situation, based on actual research of your site.
  • The first priorities, with a reason for each.
  • A realistic timeline with expected milestones.
  • Who will do the work, and how often you’ll meet.
  • How results will be measured and reported.

Proposals that could have been sent to any store, with no specific findings about yours, are a warning sign.

Weigh the timeline honestly

Agencies sometimes compete on speed. Be careful with promises that sound too fast. An Ahrefs study of 2 million new pages found that only 5.7% reached Google’s top 10 within a year, and just 0.3% did so for high-volume searches.

Established stores usually see results sooner than that, because they’re not starting from zero. A credible agency will tell you which quick wins it expects in the first months and which results will take longer.

Don’t compare on price alone

The cheapest proposal often covers less work, fewer senior hours or lower-quality links. The most expensive isn’t automatically the best either. Compare what each agency actually delivers each month for its fee.

Ask every agency the same question: what exactly will you do in the first ninety days? The answers make proposals far easier to compare than a monthly price ever will.

Making the final call

Once you’ve scored the agencies, speak to one or two current clients of your top choices. Ask how communication works in practice, how quickly issues are handled and whether the agency delivered what it promised in the proposal.

The best choice is usually the agency that scores well across the board, understands your store specifically and gives straight answers when you ask difficult questions.